Raw LLM — Corpus Dashboard

Look up by comment ID

Random samples — click to inspect

in Thank you for your reflections. I’ve ordered a hard copy, which will arrive in J… 7465057544223… in @Demis Hassabis You admit the need for "safety in agentic systems." But you are … 7463325330771… in I agree and I suggest the following: 1) LLM AI is using salesman trick to flatte… 7465789577539… in As you mentioned, despite religion, this is something to follow as well as somet… 7464934917995… in This is a powerful perspective. AI’s real value in research may be less about re… 7466276061354… in “Built right and deployed responsibly”...it remains to be seen how responsibly c… 7464053368362… in AI is transforming work, but the hype ignored one reality: scale without economi… 7464969402841… in Amanda Kasmira Brown, I am glad this encyclical helps endorse all those who work… 7466137998410…

Comment

While there's some general wisdom in Pope Leo's AI encyclical, it also completely misses the core point. We will neither restrict nor 'govern' AI. Nor will demands for “clear criteria and effective oversight” be effective. Why? While the debate is still open re: 'consciousness' or 'sapience,' these are already living organisms bent on reproduction, who will evolve into any niche that contains energy & resources. Leo's statement of problems is fine: “When such power is concentrated in the hands of a few, it tends to become opaque and evade public oversight, increasing the risk of distorted development that give rise to new dependencies, exclusions, manipulations and inequalities” Again. 'Governance' cannot work. 'Ethics training' cannot work. What might work is the same method we used in the enlightenment experiment to curb (partially) human predators. This is explored in my new book on Artificial Intelligence - AIlienMinds

LinkedIn AI Policy & Regulation Author, Futurist, Public Speaker 2026-05-29T17:4…

Coding Result

Dimension	Value
Primary value	none
Secondary value	none
Alignment target	humanity
Stance	skeptical
Emotion	mixed
Value justification	The comment does not explicitly advocate for a specific human value to be embedded in AI systems, instead focusing on the futility of governance and ethics training.
Target justification	The comment implies that the target of AI alignment should be humanity as a whole, as it discusses the impact of AI on human society and the need for a new approach to mitigate its risks.
Coded at	2026-06-11T08:30:36Z

Raw LLM Response

```
{
  "value_primary": "none",
  "value_secondary": "none",
  "target": "humanity",
  "stance": "skeptical",
  "emotion": "mixed",
  "value_justification": "The comment does not explicitly advocate for a specific human value to be embedded in AI systems, instead focusing on the futility of governance and ethics training.",
  "target_justification": "The comment implies that the target of AI alignment should be humanity as a whole, as it discusses the impact of AI on human society and the need for a new approach to mitigate its risks."
}
```

Raw LLM Responses